On Aug. 25, the Marathon Government Center hosted two sessions on a single subject. In the morning, local officials met with leadership from Citizens Property Insurance. In the afternoon, condo association leaders and owners got their turn. The meeting was organized by Fair Insurance Rates for Monroe, known locally as FIRM, and much of it covered condominium associations whose Citizens coverage was being nonrenewed because of the condition of their roofs.
Jay Adams, Citizens' chief insurance officer, gave the line that framed the day, as Keys Weekly reported: "The real takeaway here is: 'legally compliant' does not automatically mean that a building is insurable." For anyone comparing condo buildings from Key Largo to Key West, that sentence puts the roof near the top of the list. Inspection filings show what a building has done to date. The roof's age, and how the building's insurer sees that roof, tell you when the next large bill is likely to arrive.
The Insurer Keeps Its Own Calendar
Adams told the room that Citizens underwriting looks at a roof's age and also at how well the roof resists losses. He also said Citizens has some of the most lenient roof lifespans of any carrier in Florida. He gave one example from the company's side, according to FIRM's account of the meeting. Speaking about flat built-up and membrane roofs, he said, "If you're in year 15, we need to be thinking about replacing the roof because now we're at the end of our standards."
An association plans its roof work on a schedule set by its board, its engineers and its budget. Its insurer sets its own schedule. Most of the August meeting was spent on what happens when the two schedules don't match. For a buyer, the practical step is to learn both before choosing a building, because the earlier of the two decides when owners pay.
Speaking about planning, Adams called the association's reserve study "a long-term financial planning tool." A long-term plan only holds if the insurer's timeline lands later than the plan's.
A Fresh Coat Doesn't Restart the Count
Adams spent part of the morning on roof coatings, which associations sometimes apply to an aging roof. "You can't take a 15-year roof, put some coating on it and make it a one-year roof," he said. He added that a coating can leave hidden problems untouched: "There could be wet insulation, deteriorated fasteners."
FIRM president Mel Montagne said some companies advertise their coatings as "acceptable to Citizens." Steven Mostella, Citizens' vice president of underwriting, replied that the company knows of South Florida firms doing this and that its legal team is working on the matter.
For a buyer, a roof that was coated recently and a roof that was replaced recently are different answers to the same question. The number to ask for is the year the roof system was installed, and a coating doesn't change it.
What the Gap Looked Like in Marathon
The afternoon session showed what happens when the two schedules split. Adams said one local association had recently had five of its eight buildings nonrenewed by Citizens over roof conditions. Keys Weekly reported that attendees described large bills on short deadlines based on inspection results they disputed.
One board member said his association waited "many months" for an inspection report. When it arrived, he learned his building needed a roof replacement within two months, during hurricane season, to keep its coverage. Another speaker compared the association's planning horizon with the insurer's: "Now you're saying 'We'll give you one year for what the community has only assessed over 10 years.'"
A Key Colony Beach condo owner asked for the insurer's numbers to be shared early enough to plan around: "If (Citizens) has a tighter plan, that's what we need to know. Don't keep it to yourself – tell me now, 15 years ahead."
A newer roof doesn't settle the question either. According to FIRM's account, the leader of one Key West condominium association said an inspector called for a new roof on a building whose roof had been fully replaced five years earlier, with all new metal, all new underlayment and a 20-year warranty. In a case like that, the association's records of the replacement date and the warranty are the starting point for any discussion with the insurer, and a buyer can ask to see the same documents.
You can watch the full sessions on Monroe County Television or on FIRM's YouTube channel in two parts: the morning government session and the afternoon community forum. In the afternoon session, association boards describe what roof decisions cost them, in their own words.
Comparing Buildings by Their Roofs
When you compare buildings, look at the distance between an association's own roof plan and its insurer's view of the same roof. A short gap means the costs are predictable. A long gap means a bill could arrive earlier than owners budgeted for. These are the roof questions to bring to each building on a short list:
- What is the roof type on each building in the complex, and what year was each roof system installed?
- Who is the current property insurer, when is the next renewal, and has the association received any nonrenewal or roof-related notice?
- When does the association's own plan schedule the next roof replacement, and how much has it set aside for that work?
- Has the roof been coated or partially replaced, and if so, when was the original system installed?
- Are any roof assessments approved, pending or under discussion at board meetings?
Taken together, the answers show which buildings have a roof bill coming soon and which have one years away. Two units listed at the same price, with roofs on different schedules, carry different costs over the first few years of ownership.
Other Keys property decisions work the same way. Our Key Colony Beach seawall post looked at a physical component that decides whether a canalfront property keeps its rental license. Our flood insurance post looked at how a building's own features, more than its zone letter, now set the premium. In a condo, the roof belongs to the whole building, which makes it worth checking before you compare kitchens or views.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where does a buyer get roof and insurance information for a condo building? The association is the source for its roof installation dates, insurer, renewal history and any assessments. A licensed insurance agent can then talk through how a specific building's roof is likely to be viewed at renewal.
Is a recently coated roof the same as a new one? At the Marathon town hall, Citizens' chief insurance officer said a coating does not change a roof's underlying age. Ask for the original installation year of the roof system.
Where can I hear Citizens and local associations discuss this directly? FIRM posted both August sessions on YouTube, and Monroe County Television carries the broadcast. The links are in the section above.
This post is general information, not legal, insurance or financial advice. Confirm a specific building's coverage and roof status with the association, a licensed insurance agent and a qualified inspector before you buy.
If you're comparing condo buildings in Marathon, Key Colony Beach or elsewhere in the Keys and want an agent who asks about the roof before the view, Jessica Borraccino can help you put these questions to each building on your list. Let's connect — schedule your free consultation.